Camp Lejeune: Our Response and Comments to Latest VA Rule

Dear Secretary McDonald,

In review of the proposed new VA rule for Camp Lejeune, we find several items of interest that should be adjusted or considered.

1. “Adult leukemia” – Many commenting have already explained why this is vague, at best. A line by line specificity of coverage by type is warranted as replacement for this broad term.

2. Number of conditions – Please reconsider including, at minimum, ALL 15 conditions that were originally included in a 2012 Camp Lejeune law, along with adding any additional conditions that may have been recently added via CDC research since that time.

3. Federal civilian defense workers, spouses, children on base – Nowhere in this rule is any mention to include provisions which recognize that these constituencies were also exposed. Including this language would serve as a vital reference and precedent for other relevant agencies involved to move forward and take respective action for them. Some of those civilian workers, for example, were also previous war veterans and are not served by this rule.

4. “Camp Lejeune water supply” – In addition to simply ingesting contaminated water at Camp Lejeune, exposed individuals likely absorbed the volatile chemicals and carcinogens present from soil vapor that permeated many of the buildings on the base. Over time, this toxic soil vapor has penetrated buildings and the air in general, causing the need for installation of ventilators and measurement devices. There were also several reports of building evacuations due to the levels of vapor intrusion buildup discovered.

 

“As part of the degradation by-product simulation using the TechFlowMP model, results also were obtained for VOCs in the vapor phase (above the water table in the unsaturated zone). Analyses of the distribution of vapor-phase PCE indicate there is potential for vapors from these plumes to enter buildings at Tarawa Terrace I, thereby providing a potential exposure pathway for inhalation of PCE vapor. At Tarawa Terrace I these buildings would include family housing and the elementary school.” – ATSDR Analyses of Groundwater Flow, Contaminant Fate and Transport and Distribution of Drinking Water at Tarawa Terrace & Vicinity, USMC Base Camp Lejeune, NC: Historical Reconstruction and Present-Day Conditions – Chapter A: Summary Findings, July 2007, page A68.

 

Even more important, chemicals in the vapor can be inhaled or absorbed through the skin at a potency of 5x that of water ingestion. Therefore, exposure to concentrated soil vapor can be even more hazardous than drinking the contaminated water on base alone. This is why a proper and detailed soil vapor intrusion toxicity pathway should be evaluated, considered and included in current or future language.

5. Timelines/Details of Implementation – The rule lacks specificity on the exact details of VA responsibilities for implementation. There are no exact timelines regarding implementation of the rule, on channels of communication and frequency of messaging about the rule change to constituencies involved, details on processing times and resolution for prior/existing/pending claims, etc. The VA has earned a reputation, fair or otherwise, of being slow to move on issues such as these. Increased specificity would help shift that perception.

Along with all of the quantitative data presented in various other comments on this rule, we also urge you to consider the qualitative factors involved. This pollution and the poisoning involved took place for 30+ years. Resolution to this issue has dragged on for yet another 30 years. Perhaps it is time to move away from risk/cost mitigation tactics, incremental regulatory movements and hurdles, and finally address the pollution and results in totality. Go further and create an equitable resolution once and for all for EVERY citizen exposed at Lejeune.

Do the right thing for those who have worked, served or supported the defense of our nation.

Thank you.

 

 

 

Add Your Comments

comments

Civilian Exposure

Civilian Exposure is a 501(c)(3) tax-exempt nonprofit organization/public charity working to Build Awareness, Accountability and Assistance for Civilians Exposed to Camp Lejeune Water Contamination and all citizens exposed to any toxic contamination aboard all U.S. military installations. The effort continues to inform civilian employees and others affected by contamination to receive both the guidance and the justice they deserve.

About the Founder
A 20-year veteran of media, marketing, non-profits and entrepreneurship, Gavin P. Smith leads Civilian Exposure, a non-profit assisting civilians and veterans exposed to U.S. military contamination; the Keta Foundation, a collaborative foundation dedicated to mitigating modern slavery through economic improvement projects in Africa; and Gavin Consulting, a network of virtual experts serving global clients; He is also a former member of the CDC/ATSDR Camp Lejeune Community Assistance Panel. Mr. Smith holds a Master of Global Management with distinction (Beta Gamma Sigma) from Thunderbird School of Global Management, an MBA from The College of William & Mary Mason School of Business and a BA in History from Wake Forest University.

2 thoughts on “Camp Lejeune: Our Response and Comments to Latest VA Rule

  • October 20, 2016 at 3:50 pm
    Permalink

    Very Good. Thank You.

    Reply
  • November 3, 2016 at 4:36 pm
    Permalink

    For 50 years I have watched helpless while two of my immediate family have cancers skin problems a few other medical problems that could be linked.I also have had issues being born at Camp Geiger and living at base housing . I call it a travesty and a terrible injustice to the military families stationed their. Media attention heavily looking at Flint.But were punished

    Reply

Share Your Comments

error: Content is Copyright protected by law. For reprints or sourcing, please contact Civilian Exposure. Thank you.